Reputation Management

Spotting and dealing with fake reviews

0 min. reading time
Max Meegens
July 23, 2026
An unfair one-star review from someone who was never a customer feels like an attack, and the first instinct is to get it removed right away. Yet the first question is not how to take it down, but whether it is actually a fake review, because far from every unpleasant review qualifies. A fake review is a rating from someone without a real customer experience: a competitor, a bot, a former employee with a score to settle, or a confused reviewer hitting the wrong business. Those can be removed with evidence. A fair but critical review is something else entirely, and you do not remove it; you respond to it. Getting that distinction right determines whether you put your energy into the right route.

How do you recognize a fake review?

By the lack of real customer details and by patterns that do not add up. A fake review is often vague and generic, with no reference to a specific appointment, employee or situation, because the writer was never there. Other signals: an account with no history or with only negative reviews across different businesses, several similar reviews in a short period, or a complaint about something you do not even offer. A review that is clearly a mix-up, for example about a location or service that is not yours, counts as well.

Be honest in your assessment. An angry customer who exaggerates but has a core of truth is not a fake reviewer, even if the review feels unfair. Only reviews without a real customer relationship or with a clear policy violation qualify for removal. Which reviews Google removes and which it does not is covered in Google review policy and guidelines.

How do you deal with a genuine fake review?

Report it to Google and substantiate why it violates the policy. Flag the review through your Business Profile and, where possible, indicate which rule is being broken: no real experience, conflict of interest, spam or off-topic. The more concrete your case, the higher the chance the review gets removed. Do not expect an immediate or guaranteed outcome, because Google makes its own call and not every request is honored, including justified ones.

In the meantime, respond publicly as well, calm and factual, for example that you cannot find this person as a customer in your records and are having the review investigated. That shows readers the review does not add up, even if it stays up for now. How to strike that tone is covered in how to respond well to reviews.

What do you do with a fair but unpleasant review?

You respond to it, you do not remove it. Trying to get a fair critical review taken down usually fails, and it is also a missed opportunity, because your response to criticism is exactly what convinces the reader. A defensive removal request solves nothing; a thoughtful reply turns the review into proof that you take problems seriously. The full approach for critical reviews is in the perfect response to a negative review.

How do you keep fake reviews from defining your image?

By having enough real reviews, so a single fake one disappears into the crowd. A profile with twenty reviews feels every false one-star rating hit hard; a profile with two hundred genuine reviews absorbs it without effort. The best defense against fake reviews is a steady stream of honest reviews from satisfied customers. How to build that is covered in how to structurally collect more reviews.

How do you keep fake reviews on your radar?

By spotting it quickly when something comes in that does not add up, especially across multiple locations. A fake review that goes unnoticed for three weeks has already done its damage. With the RepShield spam filter in Repmanager, all reviews from all your profiles land in one place, with the urgent ones on top, so a suspicious or policy-violating review stands out immediately and you can report and answer it right away instead of discovering it late. That way you do not lose days to a review that undermines your visibility and your credibility.

Bochane saves 16 hours a month.
Find out what that means for your locations.

For franchise and multi-location organizations that want to save time and keep a grip on reputation.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
More than 35 companies preceded you — join now!
Repmanager Success Stories:
Terwolde increases the review response rate to 100% and saves 2.5 hours a week with Repmanager
Multi-brand management: How Hans Jongerius efficiently manages 5 car brands
8 locations, 13 Google profiles: How Nieuwendijk keeps multi-brand review management under control with AI
Peak-proof scalability: How Bochane Groep manages 80+ Google reviews a day without stress
From time-consuming admin to strategic impact: How Stam scaled AI Review Management across 20 locations
Win More Customers
Start Free Trial
Win More Customers
Start Free Trial
Win More Customers
Start Free Trial